Mutual Funds Commodities Research Tax Planning IPO Our Team Contact Us    

| More

Consumer Products - Cautious: Quick look back at what worked in CY2017 - Kotak

Posted On: 2017-12-21 00:15:30

Quick look back at what worked in CY2017. Stocks in our sector coverage universe delivered a simple average (not market cap weighted) return of 57% in the past one year. The range of returns was wide - from negative 10% return for S H Kelkar to 171% for Titan. As many as nine stocks (38% of coverage universe) delivered returns in excess of 60%. Common threads - (1) bulk of the returns came from PE multiple expansion; while this was true across the sector, companies that also showed decent earnings delivery saw higher degree of multiple expansion, and (2) narratives trumped numbers for another year.

CY2017: a year where a random stock pick had a 1-in-3 chance of delivering 60%+

As many as nine of the 24 stocks we looked at for this exercise delivered returns in excess of 60% in the past one year. This included names like Titan (+171%), TGBL (+151%), JUBI (+115%), Page Industries (+84%), UNSP (+83%), HUVR (+70%) and Britannia (+65%) among others. The laggards (sub-30% returns!) included the likes of GSK Consumers (+28%), Dabur (+28%), Marico (+27%), Colgate (+19%), ITC (+15%), and JYL (+12%). S H Kelkar was the only stock with negative returns in the past one year.

PE rerating the key return driver as has been the case for the past few years

PE expansion has been the key driver of returns for the FMCG stocks for the past many years; CY2017 saw the same on an overdrive. Barring SHK that saw its 12-month forward PE decline in the past one year, the simple-average forward PE of the other 23 stocks as a composite increased to 45.2X from 32.8X at end-December 2016, an increase of just a shade below 40%. On a lighter note, 'FMCG PE' as an asset class would have delivered better returns than most asset classes around the world, in our view.

From a contribution standpoint, PE expansion contributed nearly 80% to the total returns generated as forward EPS growth (earnings rollover, essentially) averaged just around 12%. We must note that this 12% increase is versus forward EPS estimates 12 months back; this was the post-demonetization period and expectations were generally very benign. We also note that the 12% average reflects a wide range of as low as flat (for names like Emami and GSK-CH) to as high as 53% for Titan. In other words, earnings delivery for most of the names has actually been subpar in the past one year. Interestingly, the highest increase in forward EPS estimates is for names like Titan, PCJ, JUBI, UNSP, etc. We must note that these were the names the Street was generally fairly bearish on, in the post-demonetization period.

So, was there a theme of the year? Yes and no

From an earnings upgrade standpoint, the themes of the year were - (1) relatively subdued expectations going into the year - names like Titan, PCJ, UBBL, UNSP and JUBI benefitted from this. Earnings surprises were rewarded with relatively higher PE expansion thereby making these stocks stand out on the performance charts, (2) early beneficiaries of demonetization and GST, especially the jewelers who showed massive market share gains, (3) select situations where the Street's fears turned out to be overdone. GST-related margin impact on the alcobev players was a case in point; GST did not impact margins of UBBL and UNSP at all, and (4) select company-specific supernormal OPM expansion situations; HUVR and JUBI were cases in point. Partial retention of GST benefits was a common margin driver. From a multiple expansion standpoint, we believe the theme of the year was a more macro one - strong flows! Bullish 5, 10, 15 and even 30-year outlooks offered by companies enhanced the generally bullish sentiment further.

Source: Equity Bulls

Click here to send ur comments or to

Disclaimer:The article above is a gist / extract of the original report prepared by the research firm / brokerage firm. This article is not to be considered as an offer to sell or a solicitation to buy any securities. This article is meant for general information only., its employees or owners or the research firms, its employees or owners won't be responsible for any liability that may arise from information, errors or omissions in these articles. or its employees or owners / the research firms or its employees or clients or owners may from time to time hold positions in securities referred in this article. For detailed research reports, please contact the concerned research firm directly.

Other Headlines:

Result Update: The Phoenix Mills Ltd - BUY - TP Rs.672 - Kotak
Result Update: Time Technoplast Ltd - BUY - TP Rs.214 - Kotak
Result Update: Shipping Corporation of India - BUY - TP Rs.110 - Kotak
Result Update: PNC Infratech Ltd - BUY - TP Rs.208 - Kotak
Result Update: KNR Constructions Ltd - ACCUMULATE - TP Rs.348 - Kotak
Result Update: NBCC (India) Ltd - ACCUMULATE - TP Rs.229 - Kotak
Result Update: Jindal Stainless Hisar Ltd - BUY - TP Rs.318 - Kotak
Result Update: NMDC Ltd - SELL - TP Rs.130 - Kotak
Result Update: Talbros Automotive Ltd - BUY - TP Rs.389 - Kotak
Result Update: Sterling Tools Ltd - ACCUMULATE - TP Rs.428 - Kotak
Result Update: FIEM Industries Ltd - BUY - TP Rs.1203 - Kotak
Management Meet Update: Escorts Ltd - BUY - TP Rs.1051 - Kotak
Result Update: GE Shipping Company - BUY - TP Rs.500 - Kotak
Result Update: Marico Ltd - ACCUMULATE - TP Rs.327 - Kotak
Result Update: Mahanagar Gas Ltd - ACCUMULATE - TP Rs.1084 - Kotak
Result Update: Wonderla Holidays Ltd - BUY - TP Rs.457 - Kotak
Result Update: Asian Granito India Ltd - BUY - TP Rs.705 - Kotak
Result Update: NALCO - BUY - TP Rs.100 - Kotak
Result Update: VA Tech Wabag Ltd - BUY - TP Rs.672 - Kotak
Result Update: Greaves Cotton Ltd - REDUCE - TP Rs.136 - Kotak
PNB's 11300 cr fraud will impact the asset quality: Angel Broking
Lambodhara Textiles Ltd Q3 net profit climbs to Rs. 3.46 crores
Result Update: GHCL Ltd - BUY - TP Rs.365 - Kotak
CHHOTA (to) Mota Ideas - Result Update: Eveready Industries India Ltd - BUY - TP Rs.530 - Kotak
Result Update: Tata Motors - BUY - TP Rs.477 - Kotak
Result Update: Bajaj Auto Ltd - BUY - TP Rs.3670 - Kotak
Views on Indoco Remedies Ltd 3QFY2018: Angel Broking
Government finally lays out a detailed roadmap for PSU banks: Angel Broking
Idea Cellular feels the pressure of Jio pricing in Q3: Angel Broking
Company Update: GHCL - BUY - TP Rs.365 - Kotak
Result Update: Zee Entertainment Exterprises Ltd - REDUCE - TP Rs.610 - Kotak
Result Update: Hindustan Unilever Ltd - ACCUMULATE - TP Rs.1520 - Kotak
Result Update: TV18 Broadcast Ltd - ACCUMULATE - TP Rs.67 - Kotak
Views on Wipro Limited 3QFY2018: Angel Broking
Yes Bank reports better than expected quarterly results: Angel Broking
Result Update: DB Corp Ltd - BUY - TP Rs.550 - Kotak
Result Update: Adani Port and Special Economic Zone (APZ) - BUY - TP Rs.485 - Kotak
Result Update: Ultratech Cements Ltd - BUY - TP Rs.4978 - Kotak
Views on HCL Technologies Ltd 3QFY2018: Angel Broking
MIRC Electronics - Initiating Coverage - Kotak
Result Update: Tata Sponge Iron Ltd - REDUCE - TP Rs.1172 - Kotak
Result Update: Hindustan Zinc Ltd - REDUCE - TP Rs.315 - Kotak
Result Update: Zensar Technologies - ACCUMULATE - TP Rs.971 - Kotak
Result Update: Cyient Ltd - REDUCE - TP Rs.689 - Kotak
Result Update: NIIT Technologies Ltd - ACCUMULATE - TP Rs.798 - Kotak
Result Update: Chennai Petroleum Corporation Ltd - ACCUMULATE - TP Rs.495 - Kotak
Result Update: ITC Ltd - BUY - TP Rs.318 - Kotak
Result Update: Kansai Nerolac Paints Ltd - BUY - TP Rs.600 - Kotak
Axis Bank flatters the street in the third quarter: Angel Broking
Energy: 3QFY18E preview-expect a strong quarter

Website Created & Maintained by : Chennai Scripts
West Mambalam, Chennai - 600 033,
Tamil Nadu, India

disclaimer copyright © 2005 - 2018